Solving complex aviation problems often starts with a conversation.
Contact Closed Loop →
© 1999–2022 Closed Loop (Australia) Powered by Allette Systems (Australia) and PageSeeder
Following parts 1 and 2, there's no doubt that in the century and a bit since the commercial aviation industry began, the successes have far outweighed the failures. Look at some of the examples.
The Sound Barrier - 33 Years
It took a relatively short 33 years to progress from a meek 55 knots to exceeding the speed of sound - Mach 1.06 (more than 600kts) at 43,000 feet in a jet-powered aircraft on October 14, 1947.
Man on the Moon - 55 years
Spacecraft reached the moon in 1959 45 years after Jannus' flight with Luna 2, an uncrewed Soviet spacecraft. Neil Armstrong walked on the moon on July 20, 1969. Interestingly, Yeager's 1947 flight spawned further research, and the X-15 exceeded five times the speed of sound in 1959, beginning the work toward crewed space flight.
The Concorde - 55 years
The Concorde first flew in 1969 and entered commercial service in 1976. It halved the flight time between New York and London cruising at more than Mach 2 (1,160+ Knots) at 60,000 feet. That's 203 times as fast and 1200 times as high as Jannus's flight.
The 747 - 55 years.
1969 was a big year in aviation. The first flight of the Boeing 747 occurred on February 9 and entered service with Pan Am on January 22, 1970. The success of the aircraft is unquestionable. It was the first twin-aisle airliner and drove the seat cost down by a third. The B747 enabled Pan Am to "democratize" air travel. Variants can carry over 360 people, almost 15,000km. In 1989, a Qantas 747-400 took the record for the longest single flight stage, London to Sydney. A flight of just over 17,000km.
The first billion passengers - 41 years.
On the 100th anniversary of Jannus' flight, the commercial aviation industry had flown more than 65 billion people. Forecasts had predicted the industry would carry the second sixty-five billion passengers before 2030 but for COVID-19 — that's a little over a sixth of the time.
The industry's staggering technical and development achievements are one thing, but there's so much more. The commercial aviation industry contributes to about 35% of world trade by value, close to three trillion dollars in global commerce, and employs more than 60 million people globally. In total, the aviation industry supports almost 4% of global GDP.
Setting aside, for now, the disruptive 2020 crisis, and from which the industry will recover over time - even if not as quickly as some aviation commentators predict - the sheer weight of numbers associated with that success had become a problem of a different kind, one which was sapping the industry from within.
While the COVID crisis remains front-of-mind and the vast numbers associated with it, and its medium-term effects are challenging to comprehend, it is hard to take a perspective that, like most of the disasters that preceded it, it is not of the industry's making.
However, the pre-crisis, circa $66 Billion (and growing) annual cost of system inefficiency most definitely is.
The issues the industry is collectively facing are - or were before the virus - quite broad. Lumping them into the simple figure expressed like it is above doesn't tell the full story, and neither is the figure shown above reflective of the real costs with which the industry must deal. What does 'system inefficiencies' mean? These are the estimated costs of the delays within the aviation system. Still, the number by itself doesn't fully reflect other issues like the environmental debate that has been brought into sharp focus since the virus shut down the industry in the first quarter of 2020.
In 2017, the aviation sector consumed 341 billion litres of jet fuel, costing 149 billion dollars. That fuel generated 859 million tonnes of CO2, then about 2% of total global emissions and, notably, only 12% of all transport emissions. While we sometimes allow the debate to overlook how industry innovation improved the emissions efficiency of its aircraft by 70% since the 1960s, growth trends have projected emission contributions to grow significantly with the industry’s share amplified by the changing shape of the pie as other industries abate emissions more quickly—and it must be said, more easily. The industry continues to struggle with its environmental custodianship even with the enviable record it has established.
Even as COVD-19 has, for the time being, broken all the benchmarks and caused the industry to over-achieve on its environmental targets overnight, there are things that we can do now to be ready to make significant inroads with our environmental responsibilities as the industry emerges from the virus.
A term like 'system inefficiencies' doesn't begin to reflect projections about capacity constraint, which reached a tipping point in some parts of the globe in 2017. On July 22, Heathrow reported the busiest day in its history for London ATC, with the 8,800 planned flights that day exceeding the capacity of available airspace and other system infrastructure. The announcement contained some ominous forecasting noting that by 2030, scarcity will force the cancellation of that many flights every month. But July 2017 wasn't a one-off record-setting day.
Two hundred and twenty-five thousand flights took to the air on Wednesday, 24 July 2019, and while Flight Radar 24 data only dates back to 2006, this number sets the record since then. Again, NATS, the UK's ANSP, said it expected the summer of 2019 to be the busiest on record for air traffic in Europe. July 5 surpassed the 2017 total with a new high for flight numbers on a single day when NATS handled 8,863 flights in 24 hours. But instead of being lauded with accolades, most of the commentary was negatively focussed on the environmental impact, demonstrating just how intertwined the industry is. It doesn't end there. Knowing the magnitude of potential system delays doesn't tell the entire story.
According to figures from GE, we throw away 67 million meals annually because of delays and cancellations. Considering the upstream and downstream effect of that waste, the money sent down the drain in terms of the direct per-meal cost to the airline doesn't count the real catering 'system' costs to the environment. What else do we waste as a consequence of our success?
While it simplifies things to view these issues, and others like them as uniquely different, and therefore, requiring separate programs to address them, these issues are fundamentally related to the same thing - the unbound success of the industry. So, while separating them might be convenient for the committees, and may help the understanding each issue and perhaps provide the impetus for efficiency programs driving more efficient catering load scales, it doesn't fix the problem.
The root cause is fundamentally a single-issue problem requiring a broad, industry-based, holistic solution.
The industry continues to address its problems generally via a single-issue, at times, myopic committee system organised to solve issues like the environment, congestion, scarcity, air traffic control as separate matters. Soon we'll need to address other problems looming like UAVs, sovereign identity management including, as a result of COVID-19, new health, border management and security systems, touchless airport processes and a host of other utopian possibilities. However, the long history of rigid functional structure within the aviation industry, and as ostensibly reflected in the industry's rule-making and representative bodies, makes it difficult to reset industry worldviews and admit the interwoven nature of many of the issues facing it today.
Trajectory Based Operations (TBO) is not a cure-all for what ails the industry. At its core is the strategic and holistic management - as opposed to control - of air traffic around the globe. But it's what is under the hood that provides potential pathways to radically improve the issues highlighted above, as well as quite a few others.
TBO is not a new concept, and the industry has been evolving - albeit (too?) slowly - toward a global environment that is conducive to realising the broad and deep operational and financial efficiencies that it heralds. But the aviation industry moves slowly. So slowly, that for all the benefits TBO will provide, some of which we'll discuss below was quietly pushed out from 2028 to 2032 before we'd even heard of COVID-19. Not because the concept is flawed, not because the technology wasn't ready, but because airlines don't view it as the crucial imperative to their survival that it is. Is it because they don't 'get it', or is it something else more fundamental about how airlines understand what strategy is? One has to wonder why airlines have overlooked it when the direct and, the just as critical, indirect benefits surface.
We'll leap in and propose that all things being equal, between contrails, holding,
route optimisation and reduction of cancellations,
TBO will have the most immediate impact on emissions since COVID-19.
While the industry waits for electric (or hydrogen) propulsion for shorter flights, or significant improvement in engine and biofuel technology, TBO will put its stamp on the environmental debate almost immediately.
The commercial aviation industry has thrived since 1914, despite the setbacks. It is multifaceted, demonstrated by its ability to engage with every aspect of global trade, travel, and tourism. Its remarkable record with technology has driven the development of aircraft and the systems necessary to keep 4 billion people a year moving around the globe and continuing to ensure the financial viability of airlines with capabilities like yield management systems, demand-based and customer-based fares, and intelligent network scheduling systems finding optimal timetables. Technology has also reduced its early environmental footprint by 70%, although it has got further to go to keep up with community expectations - as well as perhaps trumpeting its credentials. The industry is not sitting idly by with its environmental responsibilities. Operationally, it has become and remains the safest way to travel. Its success is boosted because while once it was the purview of the rich, it is now a commodity almost everyone can afford.
Despite all the successes, the industry has its issues, too. Its size had, before COVID-19, grown to the point that there were times there wasn't enough air in the air to put all the aircraft that demanded it. Neither is on the ground in some parts of the world. Scarcity was a word that was entering the lexicon of aviation driven by rampant competition and demand because of its affordability, benefiting everybody - except sometimes, the airlines and the industry's associated businesses that are left to shave the already razor-thin margins, a hallmark of the industry, by $60b a year. Margins so thin, that any bump in the road is destabilising to the core. The GFC, 2001, and SARS all tested us, but the industry always overcame and regained its impressive growth trajectory. COVID-19 will be no different in time.
The sombre news that attaches to this crisis differs from the others that preceded it. The depth of the crash in demand and supply forced on the industry by global border closures and the shutdown of international, inter, and intrastate travel is unprecedented. While some pundits have been discussing optimistic emergence timeframes and recovery, some airlines have recognised the inevitability of a smaller industry on the other side, uttering 3-year-plus timeframes for the sector to regain its 2019 position. Many have already been taking action to reposition for a different world for a while. Yesterday, Qantas announced that a fifth of its workforce would not have jobs at the end of this, so dire is the nature of this crisis. Qantas is not alone. With few exceptions, Qantas among the fortunate, not many airlines went into this crisis with the ability to withstand what COVID-19 has wrought.
Benjamin Franklin said, "out of adversity comes opportunity."
While all industry participants look to the industry's re-set, there are opportunities to build a more agile and resilient future for the industry and our customers and to achieve the ability to do so much more with less as the commercial aviation industry regains its footing and continues its own journey higher.
Ruthless evaluation of entire operating, procedural and IT systems will be required to eliminate everything that doesn't add value.
At Closed Loop, we believe the industry will grasp the lessons from this crisis and take the opportunity to reset the sector on a footing of agility and resilience. It'll take work, look different, and require acceptance that change will be inevitable. Ruthless evaluation of old thinking and old systems will make way for new methods and new technology enablers. This new direction will be a digital world where connectivity, data integration, collection and connection will be the new norm. It will enable new operating models to bridge the post-COVID world of distributed ledgers containing identity, health data, and journey details that can track every connection, relationship, and touchpoint. It will prepare the road for seamless implementation of TBO as the industry tempo picks up again.
Connectivity, data integration, collection, and connection will be the new norm. They will be necessary for survival.
TBO is almost a utopian vision for the industry, but a workable one even today. TBO and the new digital world in which it will operate will integrate the operation from upstream of customer arrival at the airport, through the airport and into the aeroplane, throughout the flight to the endpoint of the customer journey. The customer journey and the relationship with the customer will be the airline's focus, and old functional silos, the bastions of airline inefficiency, will erode and become integrated facilitators of that journey. Consequentially, environmental outcomes will improve, and waste reduction will occur due to the evaporation of the system inefficiencies and its $60b in today's figures price tag.
Sacred cows have no place in the airline, the airport or any part of the customer
journey ecosystem.
It's time for the industry to 'clean house.'
TBO is a well-developed and developing concept. New data standards already exist, so does SWIM. New digital technology enablers are working for some airlines now. What is needed are the processes and procedures that make them work and from which the value flows.
Closed Loop has frameworks to help airlines take advantage of the changing landscape in operating and operational nuance. Get in touch to arrange an obligation-free chat and set your strategy on a course to agility, resilience and the future.
For those who want to participate in reshaping the future and changing the self-reflective worldview of the industry into a utopian vision of what could be, like the potential described in this blog, Closed Loop has created the_Loop for airline, airport and industry visionaries to share ideas, ideals, and collaborate to change the world. Take a look at the introductory page and let us know if you want to become an agent for change by signing up.
Solving complex aviation problems often starts with a conversation.
Contact Closed Loop →
© 1999–2022 Closed Loop (Australia) Powered by Allette Systems (Australia) and PageSeeder